Politics of News and Discourse
10:30 AM - 12:00 PM, K8652
Chair: Dr. Sarah Ganter
10:30 AM - 12:00 PM, K8652
Chair: Dr. Sarah Ganter
This presentation builds on my thesis research findings to challenge the modulations within the regulatory biopolitical processes of ‘post-pandemic’ discourses within Canadian news media, proposing discursive forms of resistance to constructions of “vulnerability”. My research took a temporal approach to understand how such constructions surrounding COVID-19 risk emerged over various newspaper sampling timelines, reflecting the modulations and fluidity of discourses. Grounded in the Foucauldian tradition, this work interrogated socio-political relations and notions of “immunity” present in Canadian newspaper articles (n=352) from March 2022 to July 2024 in their discursive construction of a ‘post-pandemic’ that ‘Othered’ populations deemed as “vulnerable”. For a patient-centered analysis on these news representations, I interviewed British Columbians with Long COVID (n=10), who proposed recommendations to counter existing constructions within news media around “vulnerability” and COVID-19 outcomes. Drawing on Foucault’s work on biopolitics and Butler’s “vulnerability”, I outlined the intersections of ableism, social disparities, and stigma faced by people with Long COVID and disability communities. My research identified biopolitical discursive choices that categorized groups as deserving of access to life, and others not. My combined findings from my news media analysis and patient interviews provided insights into how we may disturb the manufactured consent to ableist discourses.
This presentation builds on my thesis research findings to challenge the modulations within the regulatory biopolitical processes of ‘post-pandemic’ discourses within Canadian news media, proposing discursive forms of resistance to constructions of “vulnerability”. My research took a temporal approach to understand how such constructions surrounding COVID-19 risk emerged over various newspaper sampling timelines, reflecting the modulations and fluidity of discourses. Grounded in the Foucauldian tradition, this work interrogated socio-political relations and notions of “immunity” present in Canadian newspaper articles (n=352) from March 2022 to July 2024 in their discursive construction of a ‘post-pandemic’ that ‘Othered’ populations deemed as “vulnerable”. For a patient-centered analysis on these news representations, I interviewed British Columbians with Long COVID (n=10), who proposed recommendations to counter existing constructions within news media around “vulnerability” and COVID-19 outcomes. Drawing on Foucault’s work on biopolitics and Butler’s “vulnerability”, I outlined the intersections of ableism, social disparities, and stigma faced by people with Long COVID and disability communities. My research identified biopolitical discursive choices that categorized groups as deserving of access to life, and others not. My combined findings from my news media analysis and patient interviews provided insights into how we may disturb the manufactured consent to ableist discourses.
At the end of March 2022, the Ukrainian media outlet Graty published one of the first witness accounts of a Mariupol resident describing the process of passing through the Russian-set "filtration camps" in Russian-occupied territories of Ukraine. As was later revealed by numerous journalistic and human rights investigations, in these facilities forcibly deported Ukrainian civilians were screened and questioned, with their biometric and digital data extracted; those rendered "suspicious" during the filtration process faced the possibility of physical abuse and/or extrajudicial detention. The "filtration camps" formed one node within the broader logistics of the forced transfer of Ukrainian civilians to the territory of the Russian Federation in the spring of 2022, where Ukrainian citizens were placed into "temporary accommodation centers" (TACs) across Russian territory. In this paper, I attend to the previously underdocumented experience of placement of Ukrainian citizens in TACs. By looking into the logistical and discursive organization of the Russian state-organized resettlement of forcibly deported Ukrainian citizens inside Russia, I aim to map out the way the figure of the Ukrainian refugee was constructed during this process, with their "refugeeness" used as a "moral-political tactic" (Lippert, 1999) by the Russian state in its efforts to mobilize the discourse of humanitarianism around forced deportations.
Digital journalism heightens visibility while expanding exposure to networked harassment. This paper reads online violence against Black women journalists as algorithmic modulation, where platforms continuously recalibrate visibility, affect, and attention to produce differentiated vulnerability. Drawing on Deleuze’s control societies, it argues that platform governance no longer relies on fixed discipline but on dynamic modulation that adjusts exposure and amplification in real time. Here, Black women journalists occupy “affective visibility positions,” where high professional visibility meets racialized and gendered risk.
The paper uses a comparative frame to examine Canada and Kenya as distinct yet interconnected digital environments. In Canada, algorithmic amplification and institutional racial bias fuel sustained, often subtle harassment. In Kenya, modulation is shaped by political contestation, electoral cycles, and coordinated digital publics that produce intense harassment events. In both cases, visibility is produced by platform logics that prize engagement, conflict, and emotional intensity.
The paper also shows how resistance appears in practices that disrupt modulation: digital refusal, collective solidarity, and strategic reconfigurations of visibility. By combining Black feminist theory, platform studies, and surveillance scholarship, it advances the concept of affective visibility modulation as a way to understand how digital infrastructures govern both harm and resistance in contemporary journalism.
Sarah Anne Ganter (PhD, University of Vienna, 2017) is an Associate Professor of Communication and Cultural Policy in the School of Communication at Simon Fraser University. At SFU she is the Director of the Digital Content & Platform Governance Lab. She is an expert in the areas of media governance and media policy in the digital era, journalism and other content industries, comparative and cross-border research. Her expertise includes analyzing media and digital policy transformations from a theoretical perspective that focuses on the dynamics and interactions shaping institutional fields. Dr. Ganter’ s work is influenced by a cosmopolitan approach to academic work, integrating scholarly work from different cultural, linguistic and geographical academic settings.
For a complete overview over Dr. Ganter's research, please consult her faculty bio, Google Scholar and Research Gate profiles, or her personal website.
Kayli (she/her) is a recent MA graduate from SFU's School of Communication, and a Knowledge Mobilization Specialist in the Faculty of Health Sciences. Her research background is on Long COVID, public health, biopolitics, and news media analysis. She enjoys engaging in knowledge translation, Long COVID advocacy, and science communication.
Vinisa (she/her) is a PhD student at the School of Communication SFU and a Research Fellow at the EDIT Projects. Her doctoral research examines how independent media in Indonesia construct counter-narratives around environmental issues, with a focus on digital journalism, discourse theory, and critical discourse analysis. She is particularly interested in the intersections of media autonomy, environmental advocacy, and democratic politics in post-authoritarian contexts.
Daria Hetmanova (they/them) is currently pursuing their PhD at the School of Communication at Simon Fraser University, Canada. Working at the intersection of science and technology studies and critical security studies, Daria currently focuses on analysing the Russian-established infrastructure of “filtration” during Russia’s war against Ukraine.
Joan Letting (she/her) is a PhD student at Simon Fraser University, Canada, whose research sits at the intersection of media, journalism, and digital cultures in Africa. Her work examines how platform infrastructures shape participation, visibility, and collective memory, with a focus on Kenya and other African contexts. Adopting feminist digital ethnographic approaches, she explores online violence, counter-memory practices, and the role of everyday digital communication in reconfiguring public discourse. She is also interested in African storytelling, humour, and creative expression as forms of resistance. Joan has professional experience in journalism and digital communication from Kenya, bridging academic research with policy and public-facing conversations.